The way this game is likeliest to play out is a shootout. Duh. But there are some question marks on both sides that could lead things to play differently.
In cash games, my player pool consists of the quarterbacks, kickers, Hurst, and then Chase if I can afford one of the high-end skill position plays, with Cook as a reasonable mid-range option if needed.
In tournaments, Chase is my favorite captain (and the best option, in my opinion), but I also want to be overweight on Davis and all of the running backs.